Click here for search results

Newsletter

Site Tools

Improving Indoor Air Quality for Poor Families: Controlled Experiments in Bangladesh

Authors:Susmita Dasgupta , Mainul Huq , Dr. M. Khaliquzzaman  and David R. Wheeler
Topics:Environment
Report Number:wps4422
Citation: 

Indoor air pollution (IAP) is dangerously high for many poor families in Bangladesh. Concentrations of 300 ug/m3 for respirable airborne particulates (PM10) or greater are common in Bangladeshi households, implying widespread exposure to a serious health hazard.

To promote a better understanding of IAP, in 2003, the World Bank’s research department has investigated the IAP in Bangladesh using the latest air monitoring technology and a national household survey (IAP Research, Phase I). The analysis of determinants of IAP verifies the  IAP reducing potential of clean fuels (kerosene, natural gas, etc.), but the nationwide survey results revealed: Poor households in Bangladesh (like in other parts of Asia and Latin America) almost always use “dirty” biomass fuels, because in most rural areas, clean fuels are not available at all. Even where a clean fuel is available, poor households prefer and use “dirty” fuels because the relative price of the “clean” fuel is simply too high. Improved stoves for biomass combustion could help but, as other studies in Asia and Latin America have also discovered, the World Bank survey found almost no adoption of improved stoves despite widespread promotional efforts in Bangladesh. Households report non-adoption for a variety of reasons, including capital and maintenance costs, inconvenience, and incompatibility with food preparation traditions. Thus, neither clean fuels nor improved stoves offer strong prospects for reducing IAP in the rural area in near future.

Fortunately, the World Bank study has identified another option that looks much more promising. In Bangladesh, common variations in certain household characteristics -- construction materials, space configurations, cooking locations and use of doors and windows -- have produced large differences in IAP exposure. As a result, some poor households using “dirty” fuels enjoy indoor air quality normally associated with clean fuels, while others suffer from pollution levels ten times the international safe standard. Since many poor households already have some of the relevant characteristics, they are clearly acceptable and affordable in Bangladesh. The IAP-Phase I research, therefore, has tentatively concluded that a national “clean household” promotion program, combined with effective public education on the associated health benefits, could reduce IAP exposure to much safer levels for many poor families.

Although the general results are quite robust, the first-round research has only been able to consider a subset of feasible measures that might yield significant benefits in this context. Before proposing a national “clean household” program to policy makers, one needs to establish a broader and more rigorously-confirmed set of clean characteristics as well as to assess their cost effectiveness in different regions of Bangladesh. Current research in Bangladesh has conducted a program of direct, controlled experimentation and cost-effectiveness analysis that will provide the needed evidence. The experimentation of the research is confined to structural arrangements(building materials, cooking locations, window/ door configurations etc.) that are already common among poor households in Bangladesh.

The World Bank study has used two types of equipment: real-time monitors that record PM10 at 2-minute intervals, and air samplers that measure 24-hour average PM10 concentrations.

  1. 1. The real-time monitoring instrument is the Thermo Electric Personal DataRAM (pDR-1000). The pDR-1000 uses a light scattering photometer (nephelometer) to measure airborne particle concentrations. The operative principle is real-time measurement of light scattered by aerosols, integrated over as wide a range of angles as possible. At each location, the instrument operated continuously, without intervention, for a 24-hour period to record PM10 concentrations at 2-minute intervals.
  2. 2. The other instrument used in the study is the Airmetrics MiniVol Portable Air Sampler (Airmetrics, 2004), a more conventional device that samples ambient air for 24 hours. While the MiniVol is not a reference method sampler, it gives results that closely approximate data from U.S. Federal Reference Method samplers. The MiniVols were programmed to draw air at 5 liters/minute through PM10 particle size separators (impactors) and then through filters. The particles were caught on the filters, and the filters were weighed pre- and post exposure with a microbalance.

Access to Datasets

The readings of pDR-1000 and MiniVol air sampler provide a detailed record of IAP concentration in each house.

pDR-1000 monitored PM10 data

Primary data on PM-10 concentrations in indoor air of 89 combinations constructed for the experiment in Bangladesh. In each case PM-10 concentrations were recorded by Thermo Electric Personal DataRAM (pDR-1000) at 2-minute intervals for a 24-hour period. Indoor air for these houses were monitored during the two time periods. The detailed information include: (i) construction material of the house, (ii) configuration of the kitchen, and (iii) type of cooking fuel.

  1. PDRAM Data-Apr05-Dec05   (MS Excel file, 16.5mb)
  2. PDRAM Data-Dec05-May06 (MS Excel file, 15.2mb)

MiniVol monitored PM10 data

Primary data on 24-hour average PM-10 concentrations in indoor air of 337 combinations constructed for the experiment in Bangladesh as recorded by Airmetrics MiniVol Portable Air Sampler during pre-monsoon period of 2005 and post-monsoon period of 2005 and early 2006. The detailed information include: (i) construction material of the kitchen and living room, (ii) configuration of the kitchen, (iii) type of fuel used for cooking, and (4) position of the stove.

  1. Minvol Pre-Monsoon Data  (MS Excel file, 214kb)
  2. Minvol Post-Monsoon Data (MS Excel file, 85kb)

Kitchen configurations in Bangladesh (MS PowerPoint file, 18kb)




Permanent URL for this page: http://go.worldbank.org/CBTAFI0CD0